Submission Feedback

Journal Submission Editorial Board Feedback

Using Microsoft Word’s comment and track change tools, specifically address issues within the paper. Once complete, save the document as a new file, adding your initials at the end of the file name. Take care not to identify yourself while in the process of making comments or suggested edits to ensure feedback to the author is de-identified. Then, complete the form below, and upload the paper with tracked changes incorporated.

* Indicates required field

Editor Name *

First

Last

Email *

Title of Paper *

Rank the extent to which the paper meets criteria expectations:

The author provides strong evidence for conclusions *

The paper topic is of interest to educators, researchers and/or those in the aviation maintenance industry *

The paper topic assesses unique or novel issues in a way that is likely to influence thinking in the field and/or introduces innovations in teaching or practical project application *

The paper is free of spelling and grammatical errors *

The paper was provided in an easily readable and editable format, in accordance with the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association style guide *

The paper is supported by appropriate literature. The literature is referenced within the paper and contained in a reference list given at the end of the paper. Note: The supporting literature need not always be exhaustive in length, and for articles the focus of which is the use of a mock-up or equipment developed for teaching laboratories, it may be minimal. *

Your opinion on the overall quality of the paper *

Exceeds expectations Meets expectations Needs improvement

Your recommendation for publication *

Publish as is Publish after edits Reject for publication

Other comments? *

Upload the track-changed Microsoft Word article *

Max file size: 20MB

​Journal Submission Editorial Board Feedback

Aviation Technician Education Council​​atec@atec-amt.org • 703.548.2030P.O. Box 234 • Jenks, OK 74037​© 2020 PRIVACY POLICY

Journal Submission Editorial Board Feedback

Aviation Technician Education Council
atec@atec-amt.org • 703.548.2030
P.O. Box 234 • Jenks, OK 74037
© 2020 PRIVACY POLICY